Feds
go after fitness group that Doyle embraced
May
22 -- Federal prosecutors are investigating
the National School Fitness Foundation, a charity
that Gov. Jim Doyle endorsed by name in his state
of the state address in January.
A
federal judge in Minnesota this week froze the Utah
organization's assets and ordered it to stop selling
fitness equipment to schools in the state.
"There
is probable cause to believe defendants have committed
and continue to commit federal mail and wire fraud,"
said U.S. District Court Judge Richard Kyle in St.
Paul, according to the Associated Press.
Doyle
in January announced a $10 million private-public
partnership with NSFF, but withdrew his support
when Minnesota officials said it appeared the organization
was running a Ponzi scheme.
Gov's
pic gone, but endorsement stands on web site
May
11 -- Gov. Doyle's grinning gums are gone
from the National School Fitness Foundation's web
site home page, but word of his endorsement
remains.
The
site continues to feature pictures and video of
Doyle in its media
section.
The
home page pictures of Doyle were gone by mid-day
Monday. Doyle requested last week that all references
to his support of the firm be removed from the site,
but as of Tuesday, the site still proclaims: "Wisconsin
Governor/NSFF enter $10 million partnership."
Doyle,
who announced the partnership with the firm during
his State of the State address in January, withdrew
his endorsement of the firm last week after a Minnesota
official said the company's operations could be
a ponzi scheme.
NSFF
also suspended payments to school districts (see
story below).
Doyle-backed
fitness program a "ponzi scheme," Minnesota
official says
Governor
distances himself
May
8
-- A school fitness equipment program publicly endorsed
by Gov. Jim Doyle in his State of the State speech
appears to be a huge ponzi scheme, a Minnesota state
official says.
A
Doyle spokesman said Friday the governor no longer
supports the program, which was supposed to provide
schools with expensive equipment at no cost to them.
The
program's vendor, the non-profit National School
Fitness Foundation, announced this week that it
would delay issuing reimbursement checks to hundreds
of school districts that made up-front payments
for the the equipment. The schools expected the
foundation to pay them back.
Minnesota
AG Mike Hatch said the foundation and its operations
have "all the signs of ... the largest Ponzi
scheme we've seen ever," according to the Minneapolis
Star Tribune.
Just
four months ago, Doyle wanted to team up with NSFF
in a $10 million public-private partnership to put
fitness equipment in 100 schools. On Friday, though
a Doyle spokesman said the governor is revoking
his endorsment and has asked NSFF to remove any
mention of his backing from its promotional materials.
As
of Saturday morning, however, Doyle still was prominent
on the foundation's home
page.
Doyle's
reversal came the same week a National School Boards
Association web site asked if NSFF is the "Enron
of Education."
At
least one Wisconsin school -- Gerritts Middle School,
in Kimberly -- has acquired fitness equipment through
the foundation.
Federal
tax documents show the non-profit was profitable
for President Cameron Lewis, whose salary rose from
$155,000 in 2000 to $317,358 in 2001. Foundation
Chairman J. Tyron Lewis wasn't paid in 2000, but
got $52,500 for working 20 hours a week in 2001.
Hatch said the foundation's unaudited liability
was about $77.5 million as of Dec. 31, according
to the Star Tribune.
“Usually
a Ponzi scheme involves little old ladies,"
he said."To be able to take that kind of money
out of government agencies is stunning," he
said.
NSFF
sells school districts on a program, known as "LIFT
America," by getting the districts to make
up-front payments for equipment and services. NSFF
assures the districts they will be reimbursed for
their costs, according to School
Board News.
NSFF
says it receives money to reimburse schools from
federal grants and contributions from private foundations,
but Minnesota officials allege that the company
is relying on "royalty payments" from
districts it has recently signed contracts with
to reimburse districts that have been in the program
longer.
The
Minnesota Department of Commerce last month issued
an "order
to show cause" why the NSFF and
its authorizing agent, School Fitness Systems (SFS),
should not be stopped from doing business in the
state.
At
issue is whether the firms made "fraudulent
or deceitful statements, material misrepresentations,
or omissions" concerning the LIFT America program,"
according to the order. A prehearing has been scheduled
for May 20.
The
order describes a typical sale: a school pays $222,000
to School Fitness Systems, which covers the cost
of equipment, training, and shipping; a $3,000 fee
to SFS; and a "royalty payment" of approximately
$134,000 -- or 60% of the purchase price -- to NSFF.
The
majority of vendors that supply the equipment and
services are "directly or indirectly affiliated
with, owned, controlled or operated by" current
or former NSFF or SFS owners or officials, according
to the order.
The tax documents show NSFF paid $342,500 to School
Fitness Systems in 2001 for "equipment procurement."
NSFF
also paid $156,000 to a firm called Blackwell for
"administrative services" and $65,000
to Compass Development for consulting. All the entities
-- the National School Fitness Foundation, School
Fitness Systems, Blackwell, and Compass Development
-- shared the same American Fork, Utah address.