Storyhill Logo

The Story Hill News & Issues Page
Check Out Other News & Issues Pages

Great work if you can get it
Marquette Interchange consultants offered $25,000 to go to a single meeting

Also on this page:

Mixed bag in Senate transportation bill.

DOT's $4 million, no-bid start to Marquette Interchange work.

Five Republican legislators seek DOT accountability.

 

Feb. 20 -- The State Department of Transportation offered its Marquette Interchange consultants more than $25,000 to prepare and participate in a single public meeting, records show.

Jim Rowen, a Marquette Interchange critic and political commentator, said the money was "taxpayers' money simply wasted."

CHM2 Hill, at the time the no-bid main contractor for Marquette Interchange design study, was offered $10,946.28 to participate in a fourth public informational meeting, according to a 2002 contract amendment obtained by the webteam through an open records request.

HNTB, then a subcontractor to CH2M Hill, was to be paid $15,852.64 to help prepare and conduct the public information session.

There was no requirements for the amount of work that HNTB would have to do for that money, according to the documents.

"There must be people
working for HNTB/CH2M, or WisDOT, who could routinely handle these tasks - - like meeting site arrangements and news releases which these days is done by email and fax," Rowen said.

The only contingency on the total of $26,798.92 to be paid was that the Legislature would have to provide a budget big enough to accommodate it.


Mixed bag in Senate transportation bill

Feb. 20 -- The $318 billion federal transportation adopted by the Senate this month would increase air pollution and reduce environmental review requirements, according to the Natural Resources Defense Council.

It would also, however, require that wildlife and spraw issues be considered when officials are plannign transportation projects.

President Bush has threatened to veto the Senate version of the bill because of its large price tag.The House version of the six-year bill would be even larger -- $375 billion -- and work on it is expected to continue for several months.

The Senate bill would limit controls on car and truck emissions of ozone-causing pollutants, according to NRDC.

The bill also includes provisions that would restrict environmental review and public comment on transportation projects.

On the other side of the environmental ledger, the bill would fund a $958 million
program to reduce water pollution from transportation project runoff, which is responsible for nearly half of the pollution in our nation's waterways, according to NRDC.

The bill also would maintain the current ratio of funding for public transportation.


DOT's $4 million, no-bid start to major Marquette Interchange work

Feb. 15 -- A politically-connected engineering firm got a lucrative no-bid contract for Marquette Interchange work after the State Department of Transportation revived a dormant, 7-year-old contract with the company and added $4 million to the deal, DOT records show.

An official of the firm, CH2M Hill, donated $500 to Gov. Tommy G. Thompson's campaign fund while the contract was pending. CH2MHill employees donated a total of $6,250 to Thompson's campaign fund from 1991 through 2000, according to the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign.

"Now that the Marquette Interchange is on the front page, we need to think about consultant selection and budgets," DOT official Arthur Cupps wrote in an e-mail in May 1999. "CH2MHill was selected in 1992 for the Marquette Interchange thru design study report. There is approximately $400,000 remaining encumbrence under there current contract. It is anticipated an additional $2,000,000 will be needed to bring a DSR...New solicitations are not required, since the work scope has not changed since the 1992 solicitation."

CHM2 Hill's Patrick Klampe was designated the firm's contact for the new agreement, records show. Klampe donated $500 to Gov. Tommy G. Thompson's campaign fund in August 1999, while the agreement was pending.

The contract's price tag shot up immediately.

The new contract that DOT issued in March 2000 authorized $1.9 million for CH2M Hill and a similar amount for subcontractors, for a total of about $3.8 million, according to the records, obtained through an open records request.

By mid-2002, the value of the contract increased, through amendments, to $4.7 million, records show. Among the beneficiaries were HNTB, another firm with an open wallet for politicians, and Creative Marketing Resources, a public relations firm run by Jacqueline Moore, the wife of Milwaukee contractor John Bowles.

Bowles, who himself was a consultant for the DOT, has been implicated in the corruption case against former State Sen. Gary George. Bowles has not been charged with any crime.

CH2M Hill and HNTB still dominate Marquette Interchange work. Together, they form Milwaukee Transportation Parterns, the lead agency for preliminary and design work on the project.

The payments to CH2M Hill and its consultants were to be as follows, according to DOT documents:

  • $2.3 million to CH2M Hill for corridor engineering, field survey, public involvement, agency coordination, alternatives analysis, meetings, functional design and plans.
  • $1.65 million to HNTB for work related to public involvement, agency coordination, traffic engineering, structural engineering, report preparation and environmental documentation.
  • $381,000 to Larsen Engineers for help in field survey, agency coordination and public involvement work.
  • $56,000 to Heritage Research Ltd., for assistance on historical analysis.
  • $49,000 to Archeological Research Inc. for assistance on archaeological analyses.
  • $56,000 to Creative Marketing for public involvement work.
  • $64,000 to Lichtenstein Consulting Engineers, for bridge inspection and load rating.
  • $3,200 to 4N Consultants for community outreach efforts.
  • $100,000 for Zillman Advertising and Marketing for assistance in community outreach.

Five Republican legislators push for DOT accountability

Feb. 11 -- The State Department of Transportation would be required to report project design and scope changes so "all parties
understand when project funding needs expand beyond initial proposals," under a bill introduced this week by five Assembly members from northeastern Wisconsin.

"DOT spending on Wisconsin's major road construction program has increased over initial estimates by 70% over the last 10 years," said Rep. Karl Van Roy (R-Green Bay). "With such out of control spending and expensive cost over-runs, it is no wonder we have a budget problem."

Van Roy and State Reps. Judy Krawczyk (R-Green Bay) and Becky Weber (R-Green Bay) and State Senators Robert Cowles (R-Green Bay) and Michael Ellis (R-Neenah) introduced the bill.

“I think we have a spending problem,” Cowles said in a prepared statement. “The Legislature has not
been able to restrain itself with new road projects and there has been a serious lack of
accountability.”

The bill would:

  • Require DOT to Develop comprehensive accounting for environmental expenditures, including those for administrative expenses, maintenance, right-of-way, real estate, engineering, contingency, plus home or business relocation costs.
  • Mandate an annual report on complete expenditure information for all major highway projects to the Transportation Projects Commission and the Legislature.
  • Consistently communicate changes in project design and scope, so that all parties
    understand when project of funding needs expand beyond initial proposals.
  • Detail the amount and cost of all real estate the DOT purchases for major highway
    projects before recommending the projects to the Transportation Projects Commission.

 

storyhill.net is independently owned and operated.

Back to Top